ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
My Recreated will take a while to arrive because brexit, so I can't test myself for now, but here's an untested core. Please check if it works as expected.
I tried my best to keep the normal keys that didn't conflict with the Recreated working, but it was a hell to isolate those without breaking anything so I've finally given up: if you have both the PC keyboard and the Recreated keyboard connected, the extra keys in the PC keyboard like the arrows won't work when in Recreated mode, so you need to use caps+5,6,7,8 etc.
I tried my best to keep the normal keys that didn't conflict with the Recreated working, but it was a hell to isolate those without breaking anything so I've finally given up: if you have both the PC keyboard and the Recreated keyboard connected, the extra keys in the PC keyboard like the arrows won't work when in Recreated mode, so you need to use caps+5,6,7,8 etc.
- Attachments
-
- ZX-Spectrum-recr.rbf
- (3.03 MiB) Downloaded 370 times
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Had a go at this but in my first pass it seems to behave the same as the original core? And the arrow keys on the PC keyboard work fine, can you check if you shared the correct (modified) core?pgimeno wrote: ↑Thu Nov 18, 2021 9:06 pm My Recreated will take a while to arrive because brexit, so I can't test myself for now, but here's an untested core. Please check if it works as expected.
I tried my best to keep the normal keys that didn't conflict with the Recreated working, but it was a hell to isolate those without breaking anything so I've finally given up: if you have both the PC keyboard and the Recreated keyboard connected, the extra keys in the PC keyboard like the arrows won't work when in Recreated mode, so you need to use caps+5,6,7,8 etc.
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Yes, I've verified it to be sure. You need to go to the menu and set the Keyboard option to Recreated ZX. Take into account that this patch is not Recreated-specific, but should be applicable to the current core so that the default is the normal keyboard.
My Recreated arrived today, my wife was hiding that as a surprise I've checked it and it seems to work fine. Here's a simple BASIC program you can try to check that all key press/release combinations work:
I've noticed that the Recreated keyboard does NOT include ghosting support. I'm not sure if that's good or bad. I'll look into adding an option to the core next.
Attached is the complete patch. Now the problem is that I'm not in GitHub, so this patch can't be merged into the core unless someone submits a PR with the patch for me.
My Recreated arrived today, my wife was hiding that as a surprise I've checked it and it seems to work fine. Here's a simple BASIC program you can try to check that all key press/release combinations work:
Code: Select all
10 LET a=254
20 PRINT IN (a*256+254);" "
30 LET a=a+a+255
40 IF a>0 THEN GO TO 20
50 PRINT AT 0,0;: GO TO 10
Attached is the complete patch. Now the problem is that I'm not in GitHub, so this patch can't be merged into the core unless someone submits a PR with the patch for me.
- Attachments
-
- ZX-Spectrum-recreated.patch.zip
- (3.78 KiB) Downloaded 357 times
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Sorry, completely missed the keyboard selection option, I had assumed you had simply created an alternate "Recreated" core as a PoC.pgimeno wrote: ↑Fri Nov 19, 2021 11:46 am Yes, I've verified it to be sure. You need to go to the menu and set the Keyboard option to Recreated ZX. Take into account that this patch is not Recreated-specific, but should be applicable to the current core so that the default is the normal keyboard.
...
It works brilliantly, many thanks for doing this!!
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
You need to grab the core from this post: viewtopic.php?p=37717#p37717 then install (copy) it in the _Computer folder of the SD card.
The patch file is for submitting the changes to GitHub.
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Well, after having tried it for a while now, I can say that the experience was superb! And I'm now convinced that it's the right approach for replicating classic computers. Adding emulation hardware to it may seem like a closer replication on the surface, but in the end it loses in flexibility. The Recreated ZX creators did it right, by making only a keyboard and not a full computer. I just wish the same approach was used for other computers, like the C64, instead of having all-in-one solutions devoted to a single computer like the Ultimate 64. I'd love to have a recreated C64 USB keyboard, a QL USB keyboard and so on.
On the technical side, I have to "scold" the creators of the Recreated ZX for choosing to make shift+key combinations part of the protocol, which is a shame, but not a horribly big issue. At least they did use a unique mapping for each key.
Also many thanks to _paul_ for getting me started, by posting the link to zx81keyboardadventure.com explaining the protocol.
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
I've just reviewed some posts in GitHub. Apparently there isn't much interest in adding support for the Recreated keyboard: https://github.com/MiSTer-devel/ZX-Spec ... -711439558 (and it seems I'm not the first person to write a patch).
I don't agree with Sorgelig's argument though, as many cores get support for controllers that match the device they are for, like spinner controls for certain arcade cores. (Edit: or the 2600daptor for... guess what)
I don't agree with Sorgelig's argument though, as many cores get support for controllers that match the device they are for, like spinner controls for certain arcade cores. (Edit: or the 2600daptor for... guess what)
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
That's good to hear, because I agree with you 100%, the emulation doesn't stop at the code. I'm currently looking at mechanical keyboards that would cover the 8bit/16bit era to build a case around. The Spectrum needs those printed overlays to make any sense of the way it worked. Like you, I'd put the C64/Vic20/Pet in that category too.pgimeno wrote: ↑Wed Dec 01, 2021 12:59 am Well, after having tried it for a while now, I can say that the experience was superb! And I'm now convinced that it's the right approach for replicating classic computers. Adding emulation hardware to it may seem like a closer replication on the surface, but in the end it loses in flexibility. The Recreated ZX creators did it right, by making only a keyboard and not a full computer. I just wish the same approach was used for other computers, like the C64, instead of having all-in-one solutions devoted to a single computer like the Ultimate 64. I'd love to have a recreated C64 USB keyboard, a QL USB keyboard and so on.
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
I don't understand that. Is it a control thing about the code? If someone makes a solution I guess it's hard to bug fix with multiple authors.pgimeno wrote: ↑Wed Dec 01, 2021 1:57 am I've just reviewed some posts in GitHub. Apparently there isn't much interest in adding support for the Recreated keyboard: https://github.com/MiSTer-devel/ZX-Spec ... -711439558 (and it seems I'm not the first person to write a patch).
I don't agree with Sorgelig's argument though, as many cores get support for controllers that match the device they are for, like spinner controls for certain arcade cores.
-
- Posts: 114
- Joined: Fri Aug 06, 2021 5:30 pm
- Has thanked: 150 times
- Been thanked: 20 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Is it possible to go the other way, and get the ZX Spectrum Recreated people to add a mapping that matches what the Mister Spectrum cores use? Those guys might be motivated since they'll want to sell keyboards.
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
It's likely that they won't. https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2016 ... x-spectrum
I'm not sure but I think that it's no longer for sale. It's been out of stock every time I checked, for a long time. I got mine from eBay, used.
From the way it works (having to unlock the standard keyboard mode with a code in their page, having a custom special mapping) it seems clear that by design they don't want people to use it for anything else but their app, and that they took every precaution they could against it being adapted for use with other emulators (but people managed to do it anyway).
I'm not sure but I think that it's no longer for sale. It's been out of stock every time I checked, for a long time. I got mine from eBay, used.
From the way it works (having to unlock the standard keyboard mode with a code in their page, having a custom special mapping) it seems clear that by design they don't want people to use it for anything else but their app, and that they took every precaution they could against it being adapted for use with other emulators (but people managed to do it anyway).
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
- Chris23235
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 983
- Joined: Sun May 24, 2020 8:45 pm
- Has thanked: 127 times
- Been thanked: 197 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
If you have access to a ZX Spectrum (or an empty replica case) and a soldering iron you can convert the Speccy to an USB keyboard relatively easy.
https://www.instructables.com/ZX-Spectr ... rd-Part-1/
https://www.instructables.com/ZX-Spectr ... rd-Part-1/
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
I couldn't find these connectors anywhere though. Any references/links? Edit: Oops, I didn't see the link in the article.
Also, I guess the software needs to produce the same keyboard layout as MiSTer (SHIFT for caps shift, CTRL for symbol shift). If not, then it will need to be customized.
Also, I guess the software needs to produce the same keyboard layout as MiSTer (SHIFT for caps shift, CTRL for symbol shift). If not, then it will need to be customized.
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Okay, so as I said in an earlier post, I wasn't happy about the lack of ghosting in the Recreated keyboard (or in the core in general), so I've added it to the core as an option. I must say that I'm somewhat perplexed that the Recreated keyboard does not suffer from ghosting.
To avoid clobbering the menus too much, I've used the Keyboard option for both purposes, so it cycles between four choices: Normal, Ghosting, Recreated ZX, Rec.+Ghosting.
In addition to that, this version also fixes an out-of-specs issue with the TZX loader, where the duration of the leading tone of the standard blocks was a fixed value instead of depending on bit 7 of the first byte in the block. You know, ~5s of leading tone, header data, 1s pause, ~2s of leading tone, payload.
As always, the patch is included. The license mandates me to distribute the source code; I hope that including only the patch suffices, as it's otherwise identical to the GitHub version.
Edit: Note that most PC keyboards will suffer from key jamming, which will mask the ghosting. Also if you make your own USB keyboard using the link posted by Chris23235, you'll get ghosting for free due to the membrane design
Edit2: Removed attachments because of an important bug, see viewtopic.php?p=39308#p39308 for the fixed core.
To avoid clobbering the menus too much, I've used the Keyboard option for both purposes, so it cycles between four choices: Normal, Ghosting, Recreated ZX, Rec.+Ghosting.
In addition to that, this version also fixes an out-of-specs issue with the TZX loader, where the duration of the leading tone of the standard blocks was a fixed value instead of depending on bit 7 of the first byte in the block. You know, ~5s of leading tone, header data, 1s pause, ~2s of leading tone, payload.
As always, the patch is included. The license mandates me to distribute the source code; I hope that including only the patch suffices, as it's otherwise identical to the GitHub version.
Edit: Note that most PC keyboards will suffer from key jamming, which will mask the ghosting. Also if you make your own USB keyboard using the link posted by Chris23235, you'll get ghosting for free due to the membrane design
Edit2: Removed attachments because of an important bug, see viewtopic.php?p=39308#p39308 for the fixed core.
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
-
- Posts: 78
- Joined: Wed Nov 04, 2020 10:03 am
- Has thanked: 24 times
- Been thanked: 16 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Great fixes and additions. I hope this will be added to the official repo... I can't understand why it wouldn't be.
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
If you don't have access to Minimus then you can use cheap Arduino Pro Micro's.
The project info is on these pages:
https://mrpjevans.com/building-the-zx-r ... -part-two/
Nice thing with this one is you have keyboard mapping via a switch, so you get PC style and Spectrum layout.
I was using this method for some years until I fixed the broken Spectrum (ram chips!) the keyboard came from.
The project info is on these pages:
https://mrpjevans.com/building-the-zx-r ... -part-two/
Nice thing with this one is you have keyboard mapping via a switch, so you get PC style and Spectrum layout.
I was using this method for some years until I fixed the broken Spectrum (ram chips!) the keyboard came from.
-
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 1441
- Joined: Mon May 25, 2020 7:54 pm
- Has thanked: 497 times
- Been thanked: 467 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Whoa, I had never heard about that before! And I've played quite a lot of PC games using KB+M.pgimeno wrote: ↑Fri Dec 03, 2021 11:04 pm Note that most PC keyboards will suffer from key jamming, which will mask the ghosting.
Coincidentially, I was playing Renegade on teh ZX core yesterday using keyboard (instead of my usual DS4-as-Kempston) and could not execute the jump kick-right move (left one was fine). My keys were W/S for Up/Down, O/P for left right and ] for Hit. Could it be because of that "jamming" issue?
CRT SCR$ Project - building a collection of high-quality photos of CRT displays
CRT ART Books - retro-gaming books with authentic CRT photos
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
If it involves three keys, then most probably, yes. You can try to find a combo of keys that you can press at the same time with that keyboard without any jamming. Can't offer advice on that as it's different with every keyboard.akeley wrote: ↑Tue Dec 07, 2021 7:40 pm Coincidentially, I was playing Renegade on teh ZX core yesterday using keyboard (instead of my usual DS4-as-Kempston) and could not execute the jump kick-right move (left one was fine). My keys were W/S for Up/Down, O/P for left right and ] for Hit. Could it be because of that "jamming" issue?
I guess MAME chose Ctrl, Alt and Shift as preferred buttons mainly for that reason - they are usually separate buttons and don't suffer from jamming.
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
I may well be missing something but the tzx version does not work for me; I get this screen.pgimeno wrote: ↑Fri Dec 03, 2021 11:04 pm Okay, so as I said in an earlier post, I wasn't happy about the lack of ghosting in the Recreated keyboard (or in the core in general), so I've added it to the core as an option. I must say that I'm somewhat perplexed that the Recreated keyboard does not suffer from ghosting.
….
- Attachments
-
- 1D3C32DA-B080-4438-A22A-7979294C6E65.jpeg (152.42 KiB) Viewed 19077 times
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Sorry but I have absolutely no idea where that may be coming from. It looks like a test pattern of some sort; maybe it's not detecting boot.rom correctly for you and boots from a built-in test ROM that displays that pattern? I haven't found any evidence of such ROM though.
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
On start-up it always has this screen for me. If I reset the core (with or without making any changes to the core settings) the core boots fine.
Edit: found this in the ZX Spectrum manual
With the tzx variant I found that, with the "Normal" keyboard setting in the core settings, a key often gets stuck in auto repeat, both with my normal USB keyboard as well as with the Recreated keyboard set to PC config. It does not do that with the earlier core.
With the Recreated keyboard setting selected in the core options it works fine.
Edit: found this in the ZX Spectrum manual
I could not trigger this with the default ZX Spectrum core.The Spectrum 128 has a built-in TV test screen to ensure that you get the best possible picture and sound. You turn it
on by holding down the [BREAK] key and pressing the reset button or switching on the power. When your TV is
tuned correctly, you will see a multi-coloured pattern and hear an intermittent tone.
With the tzx variant I found that, with the "Normal" keyboard setting in the core settings, a key often gets stuck in auto repeat, both with my normal USB keyboard as well as with the Recreated keyboard set to PC config. It does not do that with the earlier core.
With the Recreated keyboard setting selected in the core options it works fine.
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
I guess it's the ghosting option that is causing problems, then. Does setting/clearing it help in any way? What's it set to by default?_paul_ wrote: ↑Sat Dec 11, 2021 8:29 am With the tzx variant I found that, with the "Normal" keyboard setting in the core settings, a key often gets stuck in auto repeat, both with my normal USB keyboard as well as with the Recreated keyboard set to PC config. It does not do that with the earlier core.
Edit: Never mind, I can reproduce the issue and I think I have identified the cause. Yes, it's about the ghosting option. I'll post the fixed core soon.
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
- pgimeno
- Top Contributor
- Posts: 710
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2020 9:44 am
- Has thanked: 277 times
- Been thanked: 226 times
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Here's the fixed core and corresponding patch.
- Attachments
-
- ZX-Spectrum-recreated-tzx-ghosting.patch.zip
- (6.42 KiB) Downloaded 318 times
-
- ZX-Spectrum-recr-tzx.rbf
- (3.06 MiB) Downloaded 323 times
Converters I've written: Floppy DIM/FDI/FDD/HDM to D88, D88 to XDF, Tape SVI 318/328 CAS to WAV
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
Seems to work! I no longer get the test screen and could not reproduce the sticky keys issue.
Re: ZX Spectrum Recreated Would Work as Bluetooth Keyboard With MiSTer?
MiSTer_Kirk wrote: ↑Thu Nov 18, 2021 2:25 pm The beauty of the Mister is that we can finally ditch that god-awful rubber keyboard, and use a modern keyboard....
I also have a few 48k spectrums here, and I try to use the keyboard less, and less. I now use a Comcon Joystick interface that allows keyboard-only games to be mapped to this device - just to avoid that keyboard.