Stunt Race FX Issues

[Storminormin]

I know I'm probably the only person in the world that cares about Stunt Race FX, but that game seems to have issues too. Side-by-side with my real SNES, I'm getting times that are significantly worse on Mister. A track that takes 1:39 to complete on SNES takes 1:49 on MiSTer. It makes the game a lot harder in the later stages. Not sure if there's anyone out there that cares enough to see if I'm not just imagining this though

[AtomicShroom]

I know I'm probably the only person in the world that cares about Stunt Race FX, but that game seems to have issues too. Side-by-side with my real SNES, I'm getting times that are significantly worse on Mister. A track that takes 1:39 to complete on SNES takes 1:49 on MiSTer. It makes the game a lot harder in the later stages. Not sure if there's anyone out there that cares enough to see if I'm not just imagining this though

While I am not equipped to compare with a real SNES, I definitely would if I could, because I do care quite a bit. I remember the original game being tight on time on the Master class, but I also remember being taken aback by how tight the timers were when I completed it on my MiSTer. Could just be that I’m not as good as I used to be, or maybe you’re not imagining things!

FBD8-CD4-F-99-B2-424-E-9006-0-FB63-FB4-E332.jpg (142.62 KiB) Viewed 16183 times

[Stupid Dufus]

Here's a brief comparison I threw together of Stunt Race FX on MiSTer vs SD2SNES on a SNES 1chip ntsc model. Unfortunately I don't have an original cartridge anymore.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IuB2hQ5z1JA

If there's something specific you'd like me to try and compare between them, I can try and do that as long as I don't have to play the game much lol Was never a big fan of it ^^;;

Also, should this be split into a new thread specific for this game?

[Xbytez]

Also, should this be split into a new thread specific for this game?

Agreed, and done

[Storminormin]

I appreciate the time you took to make and edit that video!
Unfortunately I have no idea how to edit video, or a capture card, so these two videos are the best I can do. Much less scientific than your video . Free Trax, first stage. Just holding down B from when the track loads. It does seem that MiSTer runs a bit slower, and gets more and more out of sync.
1. NA-NTSC SNES (2chip GPM-02)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7OLN870PfuE

2. MiSTer (updated core today before recording, SNES_20220519)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fANfMXKfy8

[AtomicShroom]

I appreciate the time you took to make and edit that video!
Unfortunately I have no idea how to edit video, or a capture card, so these two videos are the best I can do. Much less scientific than your video . Free Trax, first stage. Just holding down B from when the track loads. It does seem that MiSTer runs a bit slower, and gets more and more out of sync.
1. NA-NTSC SNES (2chip GPM-02)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7OLN870PfuE

2. MiSTer (updated core today before recording, SNES_20220519)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fANfMXKfy8

I took your videos and combined them into one and made sure the race starts on the exact same frame. (The timers also stay in sync throughout the whole video). What is abundantly clear is that the 3D portion on the MiSTer is significantly slower than real hardware! We definitely got a bug on our hands here.

https://youtu.be/FrbCKzAopqE

I created a GitHub ticket:

https://github.com/MiSTer-devel/SNES_MiSTer/issues/335

[paulbnl]

Free Trax, first stage. Just holding down B from when the track loads. It does seem that MiSTer runs a bit slower, and gets more and more out of sync.
1. NA-NTSC SNES (2chip GPM-02)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7OLN870PfuE

Did you use an original Stunt Race FX cartridge or an SD2SNES cart?

[Storminormin]

Free Trax, first stage. Just holding down B from when the track loads. It does seem that MiSTer runs a bit slower, and gets more and more out of sync.
1. NA-NTSC SNES (2chip GPM-02)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7OLN870PfuE

Did you use an original Stunt Race FX cartridge or an SD2SNES cart?

Original Cart. Not sure if it's relevant, but here's a pic I took of the board.

cCjkEys.jpeg (1.11 MiB) Viewed 13375 times

[Stupid Dufus]

Digging through a pile of stuff tonight I found that I do still have an actual cartridge of the Japanese version Wild Trax. So I did a comparison of the time trial mode like Storminormin did.

My results are the same. The MiSTer SNES core is definitely slower after just a minute of playing.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TK0DhknO6co

[AtomicShroom]

This thread got me reminding that not too long ago, I did a playthrough of Yoshi's Island and, having played that game a bazillion times before, I felt like portions where Yoshi was walking on the rotating map after completing a world felt strangely slower than normal. I was especially thrown off by the sounds of his footsteps not playing at the tempo I remembered them being at. Could be something else to look into while we're at it. Something might be affecting the entire speed at which the FX1 and FX2 chips are supposed to run at.

[Rahzadan]

This thread got me reminding that not too long ago, I did a playthrough of Yoshi's Island and, having played that game a bazillion times before, I felt like portions where Yoshi was walking on the rotating map after completing a world felt strangely slower than normal. I was especially thrown off by the sounds of his footsteps not playing at the tempo I remembered them being at. Could be something else to look into while we're at it. Something might be affecting the entire speed at which the FX1 and FX2 chips are supposed to run at.

This 'Slight slowness' of the GSU on MiSTer is actually similar behavior to the SD2SNES GSU core. To this day, it still doesn't run at 100% speed. I'm wondering if the implementation in MiSTer uses RedGuy's code from the SD2SNES?

[paulbnl]

srg320 made the Super FX implementation from scratch. It has been reported that the Star Fox ending runs at the correct speed unlike the SD2SNES.

Stunt Race FX enables 21Mhz mode and high speed multiplier so it is probably something related to the higher speed.

[AtomicShroom]

I did a comparison of the Yoshi's Island world map screen and it also appears to be running significantly slower than real hardware:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Nd4iAfiNK0

I don't have a real cart to test with (anymore), so I used footage from an AGDQ speedrun which (I would hope) don't let players use anything other than real hardware. If someone wants to double-check with a real cart, that would be nice. But I'm really confident MiSTer is wrong here. The AGDQ footage corresponds to what my memory remembers being the speed/tempo at which Yoshi's footsteps sounds actually play at on real hardware.

[Stupid Dufus]

I have an original Yoshi's Island cart and can throw something up in about 10 hours or so if no one else does before then.

[Stupid Dufus]

Like Stunt Race FX, the original cartridge for Yoshi's Island is again noticeably faster than MiSTer's implementation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXI-ftEh13k

[AtomicShroom]

Like Stunt Race FX, the original cartridge for Yoshi's Island is again noticeably faster than MiSTer's implementation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXI-ftEh13k

Video is set to Private. We can't view it!

[AtomicShroom]

Like Stunt Race FX, the original cartridge for Yoshi's Island is again noticeably faster than MiSTer's implementation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXI-ftEh13k

Okay it's working now! Thanks for confirming! Difference is quite clear and obvious! I will add your video to the Git ticket.

[totozero]

Hey,
Just so you know, just enabling super-fx overclock option makes yoshi's island running at the exact same speed than OG hardware.
I've just ran a comparison with Stupid Dufus video posted above and it matched quite well.

[AtomicShroom]

srg320 submitted a commit that seems to fix some of it. Maybe it’s fixed now? (Can’t really check atm)

https://github.com/MiSTer-devel/SNES_Mi ... 642bc4c516

[Stupid Dufus]

Did a new comparison using the SNES_unstable_20220815_14e889. It's slower than before, but hopefully that's just a temporary setback.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-E_moTKr3w

Not in the video is a test I did with the SFX turbo mode in the core. That was way too fast - crashed out at almost exactly 1 minute using in-game timer, whereas real hardware was at 1 min 11 seconds.

[shimian]

There's a new unstable if someone is able to test against real hardware.

[Stupid Dufus]

Did a new comparison. MiSTer implementation looks to be super close. Could even be something with the way I'm capturing and syncing stuff up. Quite an improvement from where it was months ago.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yB7EIEDsTw0